The challenge

Our client was a second-year university student who had achieved first-class equivalent grades during his first year of study.

During the autumn term of his second year, he unexpectedly lost a close family member. Recognising the impact this would have on his studies, he proactively contacted his personal tutor and discussed deferring two examinations and a piece of coursework while he dealt with the immediate aftermath of his bereavement.

Acting on advice from his faculty, he submitted an application for extenuating circumstances. While the application had been completed correctly in relation to the examinations, the coursework element had not been processed in the way our client understood. Unaware that the coursework deadline remained unchanged, he believed that the submission had been deferred to the summer term.

When the coursework deadline passed, the work was not submitted, resulting in a fail for that assessment. This had a significant impact on his overall academic performance, reducing his average mark from above 70% to below 60%.

The student submitted an academic appeal, explaining the circumstances surrounding the bereavement and the agreement he believed had been reached with his faculty. However, the appeal was rejected at the first stage because the university concluded that he had relied on provisions within its policies that did not apply to the specific facts of his case.

Our approach

We took the time to understand both the academic and personal circumstances that had led to the appeal being rejected. We carefully reviewed the relevant correspondence between our client and the faculty, together with the university’s extenuating circumstances and academic appeals policies.

Our work included:

  • Reviewing the circumstances surrounding the bereavement and its impact on the student’s studies
  • Analysing the communications between the student and university staff
  • Examining the university’s extenuating circumstances and academic appeals procedures
  • Identifying why the first-stage appeal decision had failed to address the substance of the student’s case
  • Developing legal and procedural arguments challenging the fairness of the university’s decision-making
  • Presenting a holistic case focused on both procedural fairness and the practical realities of the student’s situation.

Our strategy focused on demonstrating the appeal should not be considered solely through a technical reading of university policies. The wider context, including the support provided by the faculty, the student’s reasonable understanding of the arrangements in place, and the exceptional circumstances arising from the bereavement, all needed to be taken into account.

The outcome

The appeal was successful. The university permitted our client to submit the outstanding coursework, giving him the opportunity to improve his overall grade and ensure that his academic record more accurately reflected his abilities and performance.

Why this matters

Students facing serious personal difficulties often rely on advice and guidance provided by their university. When misunderstandings arise, or when procedures are not applied in a clear and fair manner, the consequences can have a lasting impact on academic outcomes and future opportunities.

This case demonstrates the importance of fully understanding the wording of a policy, as well as considering the individual circumstances of the student. Universities must apply their procedures fairly and consistently, particularly where students are dealing with significant personal challenges such as bereavement.

How can we help you?

We regularly advise students on:

If you have been affected by an unfair university decision, our specialist education law team can provide clear, practical advice tailored to your circumstances.

Next