Managing Conflicts of Interest in UK Company Board of Directors Meetings

Conflicts of interest can arise in any organisation, but they are especially significant within the context of a company’s board of directors. Board members are entrusted with the responsibility to act in the best interests of the company, its shareholders, and other stakeholders. When a board member’s personal interests conflict with their duties, it can undermine trust, create legal risks, and even jeopardise the company’s reputation and financial stability.

In the United Kingdom, managing conflicts of interest is not only a matter of corporate governance best practice, but also a legal requirement under the Companies Act 2006 and other regulatory frameworks.

A conflict of interest arises when a director’s personal, financial, or other interests diverge from the interests of the company. This can occur in various situations, such as due to personal relationships or personal business or financial interests.

Legal Framework: Companies Act 2006

Under the Companies Act 2006, UK directors have several statutory duties, including a duty to avoid conflicts of interest, act within their powers, and promote the success of the company. Specifically:

• Section 175 of the Companies Act 2006 requires directors to avoid situations where they have, or could have, a direct or indirect interest that conflicts, or possibly could conflict, with the interests of the company.
• Section 177 mandates that directors must disclose any direct or indirect interest they have in a proposed or existing transaction or arrangement with the company. This disclosure must be made to the board and be recorded in the minutes of the meeting.

Failure to adhere to these provisions can expose directors to legal liability and potential claims, which may lead to civil or criminal penalties.

Board’s Duty to Manage Conflicts

In addition to the individual duties of directors, the board as a whole must take proactive steps to manage and mitigate conflicts of interest. This includes the following:

• Identifying Conflicts: boards should have processes in place to ensure that potential conflicts of interest are identified as early as possible. This typically involves a combination of regular conflict of interest declarations at the beginning of each board meeting or when significant decisions are on the agenda and annual questionnaires where any potential conflicts of interest are listed, including outside business interests, investments, and personal relationships.
• Managing Conflicts: once a conflict has been identified, directors must determine whether it is material and, if so, take appropriate steps to manage it. There are several options for managing conflicts, including asking the director with the conflict to leave the room during discussions or decisions related to the conflict, ensuring they do not influence the outcome and requiring that full disclosure of the nature of the conflict be made to the board. In some cases, the board may establish a committee of independent directors (e.g. audit or nomination committees) to assess the impact of the conflict and provide oversight on specific decisions.
• Avoiding Conflicts: in some instances, the conflict may be so severe that it is advisable for the director to avoid participating in the decision-making process entirely, or even to resign from the board if the conflict is deemed irreconcilable.

Best Practices for Preventing Conflicts

Proactively preventing conflicts of interest is an essential part of maintaining good governance. Several best practices can help companies and their boards avoid or minimise the risk of conflicts:

• Clear Conflict of Interest Policy: every company should have a formal policy outlining how conflicts of interest will be identified, disclosed, and managed. This policy should be clearly communicated to all board members and reviewed regularly.
• Regular Training and Awareness: directors should be regularly trained on identifying and managing conflicts of interest, including the legal and ethical implications of failing to do so. Regular reminders about disclosure requirements and the importance of acting in the best interests of the company can help maintain high standards of corporate governance.
• Independent External Advice: for complex conflicts, especially where directors are unsure about whether a conflict exists or how to handle it, seeking external legal or financial advice can be a prudent step.
• Fostering a Culture of Integrity: a culture that prioritises ethical behaviour and integrity is key to preventing conflicts from arising in the first place. Directors should be encouraged to disclose potential conflicts voluntarily and to approach decisions with the company’s best interests in mind.

Consequences of Failing to Manage Conflicts

Failure to manage conflicts of interest properly can have serious consequences for both the director and the company. The potential risks include:

• Legal Liabilities: directors may be exposed to personal liability if they are found to have breached their statutory duties under the Companies Act.
• Reputational Damage: companies that fail to manage conflicts effectively may face damage to their reputation, especially if a conflict is perceived to have influenced a major decision or harmed shareholders’ interests.
• Regulatory Sanctions: the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and other regulators may take action against directors or companies that fail to manage conflicts in accordance with the law.

Conclusion

Managing conflicts of interest is a critical component of good corporate governance. For UK companies, the legal framework surrounding conflicts of interest, as outlined in the Companies Act 2006, provides clear guidelines for directors. However, it is equally important for boards to adopt best practices in identifying, disclosing, and managing conflicts, and to foster a corporate culture that emphasises transparency, accountability, and integrity. By addressing conflicts proactively, directors can maintain the trust of shareholders, protect the company’s reputation, and ensure compliance with the law, ultimately contributing to the long-term success of the organisation.

By taking a proactive approach to managing conflicts of interest, companies not only safeguard their legal standing but also enhance their credibility in the eyes of investors, customers, and other stakeholders.

For further information on how we can support you with matters relating to the above, please contact a member of our corporate team or submit an enquiry form, below.